What Happens if an Appraisal Comes in Low?

You found the perfect house, beat out the competition, and successfully went under contract. Everything was moving along smoothly, until you got the call with the stressful news: the appraisal came back lower than the purchase price.
If you are reading this in a panic, worried that your deal is falling apart, take a deep breath. While a low appraisal can certainly feel like a dealbreaker, it happens much more often than people think. More importantly, there are clear, practical options to keep your home purchase on track.
First, it helps to understand why a low appraisal matters. When you take out a mortgage, the home acts as collateral for the loan. To protect their investment, lenders base your maximum loan amount on the appraised value of the property or the agreed-upon purchase price, whichever is lower. Because the lender won’t finance more than the home is officially worth, a low appraisal creates a sudden funding gap that your loan will not cover.
Fortunately, you have several ways to bridge this gap. Here is a walkthrough of the options, in the order most homebuyers consider them:
Renegotiate the Price with the Seller
This is often the best and most successful first step. When an appraisal comes in low, you can ask the seller to drop the purchase price to match the appraised value. While sellers initially want top dollar, they frequently agree to lower the price. Why? Because if they cancel the contract and put the house back on the market, the next buyer’s lender will likely order an appraisal that comes back with the exact same valuation. Relisting is a massive hassle for the seller, giving you leverage to negotiate.
Cover the Gap in Cash
If the seller refuses to lower the price, or if you are in a highly competitive market where the seller has backup offers waiting, you can choose to cover the difference yourself. You simply bring the extra cash to the closing table to make up the shortfall between the lender’s maximum loan amount and the purchase price.
Meet in the Middle
Real estate transactions are all about compromise. If the seller won’t drop the price all the way down to the appraised value, and you don’t want (or can’t afford) to cover the entire gap yourself, you can meet in the middle. For example, if the appraisal is $10,000 short, the seller might agree to reduce the price by $5,000, and you agree to bring an extra $5,000 in cash to closing.
Challenge the Appraisal (Reconsideration of Value)
Appraisers are human, and they occasionally make mistakes. If you and your real estate agent believe the appraisal is demonstrably inaccurate, you can challenge it through a process called a Reconsideration of Value (ROV). It is important to note that you cannot dispute this directly with the appraiser; the request must go through your lender. To win an ROV, you will need to provide concrete evidence, such as recent comparable sales (“comps”) that the appraiser missed, or proof of factual errors in the report (e.g., listing the home as a 3-bedroom when it is actually a 4-bedroom).
Restructure the Loan
Depending on your financial situation, your loan officer may be able to restructure your mortgage to absorb the gap. If you originally planned to put 20% down, you might be able to lower your down payment to 10% or 15%, freeing up the cash you need to cover the appraisal gap. Alternatively, switching to a different loan type or adjusting your mortgage insurance strategy might provide the flexibility needed to keep the deal alive.
Walk Away (The Last Resort)
If the seller won’t negotiate, you can’t cover the gap, and restructuring the loan isn’t viable, your final option is to walk away from the deal. As long as your real estate contract includes an appraisal contingency, you can safely cancel the transaction and have your earnest money fully refunded.
How to Avoid the Problem Next Time
The best way to handle a low home appraisal is to prevent the situation entirely. First, try to avoid drastically overpaying for a home, even in a competitive bidding war. Second, if you decide to include an “appraisal gap clause” in your initial offer to make it more attractive to the seller, make sure you explicitly understand how much cash you are committing to bring if the appraisal falls short.
Finally, the most crucial preventative step is to talk to your loan officer before writing the offer. A great mortgage professional will review the numbers with you, run scenarios, and make sure you have the capital and the right loan structure to handle any surprises.
Contact Us
At Altius Mortgage in Draper, UT, we help buyers navigate every curveball the real estate market throws their way. Whether you are dealing with an unexpectedly low appraisal, looking to get pre-approved, or just want to explore your loan options, our local experts are here to guide you.
Don’t let mortgage stress ruin your homebuying experience. Contact Altius Mortgage today to speak with one of our experienced Draper loan officers and keep your home purchase on the right track!